Finding the error in a proof
A Paper 2 favourite: an argument in numbered lines, and you choose the first line that does not follow. Sometimes the conclusion is false, sometimes it is true and only the reasoning is broken. The second kind is easier to miss.
Facts checked on . Always confirm with the official source before you book.
Part of TMUA Paper 2. Jump to the 2 worked questions.
The four broken steps that come up most
- Multiplying or dividing by something that could be negative or zero.
- Squaring both sides of an equation, which can add solutions, or of an inequality, which can reverse it.
- Proving the converse: the lines show B ⇒ A, and the last line claims A ⇒ B.
- Checking examples and calling it a proof.
How to answer these quickly
- First decide whether the conclusion is true. If you find a counterexample, there must be an error somewhere, and you can feed the counterexample through each line to find where it breaks.
- If the conclusion is true, do not assume the argument is fine. Look at what each line actually assumes and what it delivers.
- Read the options before the argument. They tell you whether the question is about the first error, the type of error or whether the claim is true.
How it is scored
Each of the 40 questions (20 per paper) is worth one mark, and a wrong answer costs nothing, so never leave one blank. Your marks on both papers are scaled together into a single score from 1.0 to 9.0, and UAT-UK publishes no raw-mark conversion for current sittings.
When you practise with us you get an estimate on the same 1.0 to 9.0 scale, with its margin of error. How we estimate a TMUA score explains what that estimate is based on and when not to trust it.
Worked questions
Try each one before opening the answer.
Show the answer and the working
The answer is E.
- Test the claim: gives , which is not . So there is an error.
- Run through the lines. (I): , true. (II): , true. (III): , true.
- (IV): , false. The step from (III) to (IV) divides by , which reverses the inequality when .
- The argument is valid for only. That is the correct version of the result.
Where the other options come from
- A. The claim is false: would need .
- B. A square is never negative, so (I) is true.
- C. is correct.
- D. Adding to both sides keeps an inequality the same way round.
Show the answer and the working
The answer is E.
- Lines (I) to (III) start from " is odd" and end at " is odd". That proves: odd ⇒ odd.
- Line (IV) claims the reverse: odd ⇒ odd. That is the converse, and a proof of one says nothing about the other.
- The claim happens to be true. A correct proof uses the contrapositive: if is even, , then is even.
A true conclusion doesn't make an argument valid. Check which way each line points.
Where the other options come from
- A. The statement is true, but this argument does not prove it.
- B. The statement is true: if were even, would be even.
- C. is right.
- D. is odd, so (III) is fine.
Want more? More broken-step questions, each with a worked solution.
Not sure which topics to work on first?
The free 20-minute diagnostic asks ten questions across both papers under test conditions, then sorts your topics into gaps, right-but-slow and solid. No account needed.
Sitting the TMUA on 4 to 8 January? The January Sprint turns that result into a day-by-day plan to your test date, with full timed mocks and an estimated score after each one. It is free for the January sitting: early access, no card, nothing to pay later.
Other TMUA Paper 2 topics
- Necessary and sufficient · 2 worked questions
- Counterexamples and quantifiers · 2 worked questions
Sitting the ESAT or TMUA in 2027?
Free mock papers and booking reminders by email. Nothing else.
- New ESAT and TMUA mock papers and free practice, the day they go live.
- A reminder before each booking deadline, so you don't miss your sitting.
- Up to one email a week until the January tests, then at most two a month. Unsubscribe in one click.